| John Kinkel 1923 - 1948 |
| George McCabe, Sr. 1948 - 1950 |
| Samuel Forsythe 1950 - 1951 |
| Albert Kindleburgh 1952 - 1953 |
| Albert Glasser 1953 - 1955 |
| Dominick Aquilino 1955 - 1957 |
| Charles Crawford 1957 - 1959 |
| Eugene Powell 1959 - 1961 |
| Joseph Progreske, Jr. 1961 - 1963 |
| Walter Ragonese 1963 - 1965 |
| Walter Palmer 1965 - 1969 |
| Charles Bartram 1967 - 1969 |
| Salvatore Albano 1969 - 1971 |
| Stanley Priest 1971 - 1973 |
| Joseph Iantorno 1973 - 1975 |
| James Blair 1975 - 1977 |
| Gary Powell 1977 - 1979 |
| Alan Wiltse, Sr. 1979 - 1981 |
| Robert Nielsen 1981 - 1983 |
| Achille Patierno 1983 - 1985 |
| Raymond Thompson 1985 - 1987 |
| John Barry 1987 - 1989 |
| John Clark 1989 - 1992 |
| John Yursa 1993 - 1994 |
| Paul Aquilino 1994 - 1996 |
| Justin Kernan 1997 - 1998 |
| John Clark 1999 - 2000 |
| Matthew Halpin 2001 - 2002 |
| Andrew Klein 2003 - 2004 |
| Aric Bittker 2005 - 2006 |
| Matthew Halpin 2007 - 2008 |
| Joanne Aquilino 2009 - 2010 |
| Jason Siemers 2011 - 2012 |
| Pete Aquilino 2013 - 2014 |
| Peter Lazaro 2015 - 2016 |
| Shawn Carmody 2017 - 2018 |
| Andrew Klein 2019 - 2020 |
| Shawn Carmody 2021 |
| Andrew Klein 2022 - 2023 |
| Graham Glauber 2024 - 2025 |
